In this article
When you’re researching a move to a smaller American city, you read about median rents, walkability scores, and which neighborhoods are “up and coming” - a phrase that means prices are rising and you should hurry. What you don’t read about is property insurance, because property insurance is invisible until it isn’t.
It’s becoming very not invisible.
Hope Community, Inc., a Minneapolis affordable housing nonprofit, renewed its property coverage recently and found exactly one conventional insurer willing to offer it a policy. One. Over two consecutive annual renewals, its premiums rose 46 percent - even after the organization raised its deductible from roughly $5,000 to $20,000, meaning it was simultaneously paying more and absorbing more risk itself. When the organization hired a new broker this past spring to shop the portfolio around, the best available option was surplus lines insurance. That’s the specialty market historically reserved for risks that licensed carriers won’t touch - unusual operations, uncategorizable assets, the genuinely strange. The example used in insurance industry shorthand is a haunted house.
An ordinary Minneapolis apartment building is now in the same insurance category as a haunted house. Let that sit for a moment.
The Market Is Recovering. Just Not for This Part of It.
Commercial property insurance rates in the United States fell 13 percent in the second quarter of 2026, according to industry data - part of a broader softening in the traditional market. That headline number is real. It just doesn’t describe the market that affordable housing providers are operating in.
Kari Johnson, director of state policy for the Minnesota Consortium of Community Developers, says she started hearing from member organizations about rising premiums, shrinking coverage, and larger deductibles roughly three years ago. The conversation has since shifted. “At this point, it’s about finding coverage at all,” she said. The question is no longer whether the policy is affordable. The question is whether anyone will write one.
That distinction matters if you’re relocating to a city like Minneapolis, or Albuquerque, or any mid-sized American city where affordable housing stock is already tight and the organizations maintaining it are operating on margins that don’t absorb surprises well. When a nonprofit housing provider gets pushed into the surplus lines market, costs go up. When costs go up and rents are fixed by financing agreements and public funding requirements, something else has to give.
What Gives Is Usually Maintenance
Affordable housing owners typically cannot raise rents, even when their costs spike. Their leases and financing agreements - often involving public subsidies, low-income housing tax credits, or both - set a ceiling on what tenants pay. That ceiling doesn’t move when insurance premiums do.
So providers drain reserves. They defer maintenance. They look for additional subsidy that may or may not exist. A 2025 survey of multifamily building owners by the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis found that roughly a third reported more wind and hail exclusions than they’d had three years earlier - meaning their buildings were technically insured but increasingly exposed. Owners interviewed by the Climate and Community Institute described avoiding filing claims even when losses occurred, because the combination of higher deductibles, unpredictable claims reviews, and fear of nonrenewal made filing feel like a gamble.
Will Delaney, Hope Community’s co-executive director of real estate and wealth creation, said the organization sometimes makes the same call: when a loss falls close to the deductible, they may simply not file. The insurance exists but functions less and less like insurance.
For anyone moving into a building managed by a nonprofit or subsidized housing provider, this is the condition of the infrastructure around you - not the building’s bones, but its financial nervous system, quietly degrading.
Nobody Is Deciding This Is Fine
In Minnesota, providers are pushing to expand the state’s insurer of last resort to cover affordable multifamily properties - an acknowledgment that the private market has effectively withdrawn. Nationally, a coalition of nonprofit housing organizations has begun building its own insurance market, pooling risk across members because no one else will pool it for them.
Both efforts share the same underlying frustration: affordable housing owners often have no way of knowing whether insurers are evaluating their properties on actual risk factors or simply treating the word “affordable” as a red flag. If the latter, the market isn’t pricing risk. It’s pricing poverty.
That question doesn’t have a clean answer, which is part of why the insurance industry doesn’t advertise one.
What This Means If You’re Moving Somewhere
If you’re relocating to a smaller city and your budget puts you in the lower half of the rental market, the buildings available to you are increasingly the ones operating under this kind of financial pressure. Deferred maintenance doesn’t announce itself. A building that looks fine - and probably is fine - may have a landlord who skipped the roof inspection because filing a hail claim last year felt too risky.
This isn’t a reason not to move. It’s a reason to ask your prospective landlord who their insurer is - and to notice whether they hesitate before answering.