In this article

The housing advice most people get about New York is useless. It’s either “you can’t afford it” or a listicle of studio apartments photographed with a fisheye lens to hide the fact that the kitchen is also the hallway. What follows is neither. It’s a look at four two-bedrooms - and one one-bedroom - currently listed under a million dollars, what they actually offer, and what the trade-offs are that no listing photo will show you.

Greenwood Heights: The Duplex Next to a Cemetery

321 West 23rd Street, Unit 1C is listed at $950,000. The neighbors, as the listing casually notes, are predominantly deceased - the unit shares a block with Green-Wood Cemetery, which at least guarantees a certain noise floor.

What you get for the price is real: a duplex with a private 410-square-foot yard (laid with artificial turf, which is a choice someone made), a downstairs sleeping area with an oversized skylight and automatic blackout shades, and a renovated kitchen with light-brown cabinetry. The upstairs bathroom was given a spa renovation - Jacuzzi tub, ocher marble tile. Monthly carrying costs run $522, thanks to a tax abatement that holds through 2033. For New York, that’s genuinely low.

The catch is transit. The 25th Street R train stop is a 13-minute walk. That’s not an insurmountable distance, but in January, in the dark, after a long day, 13 minutes feels like a philosophical position on suffering. Learn the B63 bus before you sign anything.

Greenwich Village: The One-Bedroom That Photographs Like a Two

45 Fifth Avenue, Unit 15A is listed at $975,000 - technically over the informal ceiling, but worth noting because it illustrates what location premium looks like in raw form. This is a one-bedroom on the 15th floor with triple exposures and direct views of church steeples across Fifth Avenue. The rooms are proportioned like a prewar co-op from an era when people believed in ceilings. The dual-exposure bedroom reportedly fits a king bed, two accent chairs, and nightstands simultaneously.

Monthly maintenance is $1,353, which includes a live-in super and shared laundry.

You are equidistant from Washington Square Park and Union Square. That’s either a selling point or irrelevant to you depending on whether you plan to spend time outside, watching strangers fall off skateboards.

Clinton Hill: The Top-Floor Condo With the Unfinished Roof

252 Greene Avenue, Unit 4B sits at the top of a redbrick building with Romanesque Revival pretensions and is listed somewhere in the same range. The sellers spent the better part of fifteen years renovating it, and the kitchen is where most of that energy landed: Viking gas range, Thermador refrigerator, Miele stovetop, a stained-glass window, custom taps dispensing water, soda, and apparently a third liquid of your specification.

The bathroom has a sauna quality - slatted wood vanity, Jacuzzi tub, rain showerhead. The main bedroom has a decorative fireplace; so does the living room. Monthly common charges and taxes come to $1,049.

The Classon Avenue G train stop is a four-minute walk. Place des Fêtes, a wine and seafood small-plates restaurant, is at the end of the block. The unit also comes with deeded roof rights that have not yet been converted into a roof deck - meaning you’d be buying both an apartment and a home-improvement project, which is either a bonus or a warning depending on your temperament.

Carnegie Hill: Prewar Bones, Modern Concessions

172 East 90th Street, Unit 4E is the outlier in temperament. Carnegie Hill is the Upper East Side neighborhood where the preservationists are, by reputation, as immovable as the ones in Greenwich Village. The owners of this prewar co-op found a workable middle path: they kept the wood-burning fireplace and the exposed-brick wall in the kitchen, and added split-system air conditioning in every room.

Nearly nine-foot ceilings run throughout. The layout is expansive enough that the co-op reads airier than its square footage suggests.


The point of running through these four apartments isn’t to argue that New York is affordable - it isn’t, by most American standards. But the sub-million market does exist, and it’s more varied than the conventional wisdom allows. A duplex with a private yard and a $522 monthly in Greenwood Heights is a specific, real thing. So is a top-floor condo in Clinton Hill with a roof you can build on.

What the listings collectively reveal is the consistent trade-off this city runs on: space and quiet tend to cost you transit access, and transit access tends to cost you space. The Greenwood Heights duplex has the yard and the low monthlies and the 13-minute walk to the train. The Clinton Hill condo has the four-minute walk to the G - a train that is either a lifeline or an inconvenience depending entirely on where in Brooklyn you’re going.

The Carnegie Hill co-op has neither problem, and is priced accordingly.

What none of them will tell you is what the block smells like in August, or whether the upstairs neighbor has a dog.