In this article
When President Trump posted his defense of New York City’s horse carriage industry last Thursday, he made a factual error that accidentally said everything about how Americans in power think about urban space. The New York City Council had just voted 40-7-2 to end the Central Park horse carriage trade, and Trump objected on these grounds: “When there is a car accident in the area, of which there are many, they don’t stop cars from entering the Park. So why would they stop the Carriages?”
Cars have been banned from Central Park’s drives since 2018.
That ban didn’t happen overnight. It was the end of a roughly fifty-year process of city officials incrementally pulling motor vehicle access back from one of the most-used public spaces in the country. The fact that a sitting president either didn’t know this or didn’t check before posting is not, by itself, surprising. What’s worth sitting with, if you’re thinking about where to live, is what the gaffe reveals: a lot of people in positions of authority have never had to navigate a city on foot or on a bike. Their mental model of urban mobility begins and ends with a car door opening.
This matters when you’re choosing a place to live - maybe more than square footage or school ratings.
The Bike Lane as Political Symbol
The same evening Trump’s post went up, a Republican congressional candidate named Joe Mitchell was on stage at a campaign rally in Iowa, thanking the president for his administration’s efforts to rip out bike lanes in Washington, D.C. and defund bike infrastructure projects across the country. “We don’t ride bicycles in Iowa, we ride Harley Davidsons,” Mitchell told the crowd.
It got applause.
Set aside the politics for a moment and focus on the logic. The federal Department of Transportation under this administration has made it an active priority to eliminate protected bike lanes - infrastructure that, in cities like Washington, Minneapolis, and even mid-size places like Columbus and Omaha, has meaningfully changed who can get around without a car. If you’re relocating to a smaller American city and you’re hoping to live without a car, or even to drive less than you do now, the political climate around infrastructure is not abstract. It shows up in your commute. It shows up in whether your kid can ride to school. It shows up in whether the protected lane on the main commercial corridor gets ripped out before you’ve finished unpacking.
What’s Actually Happening on the Ground
In New York this week, a cyclist was hurt in a head-on collision between two e-bikes on 110th Street - a stretch that does not have the two-way protected bike lanes the city’s DOT has built on the perimeter roads of parks across the five boroughs. The absence of infrastructure and the presence of injury are usually connected. That’s not an editorial position; it’s just what the data from city after city keeps showing.
Meanwhile, New Jersey bus commuters are bracing for years of disruption as the Port Authority begins construction on a new Midtown bus terminal. The MTA is starting signal modernization on the A and C subway lines - a project expected to take six years. Six years.
If you’re moving to the New York metro area and someone tells you the transit system is “great,” ask them when they last took the A train at rush hour, or when the last time was they commuted by bus from Jersey. Infrastructure investment and infrastructure reality are often separated by a decade or more.
The Honest Question to Ask Any City
London’s Mayor Sadiq Khan announced this week that Oxford Street is being pedestrianized. Whatever you think of the comparison between London and American cities, the contrast is instructive: there, a major commercial corridor is being handed to people on foot. Here, the federal government is spending political capital to remove painted lanes.
Before you move somewhere, ask a specific question: what has this city actually built in the last five years? Not what it has planned, not what’s in a rendering, not what the economic development office puts in its brochure. What got built, and who did it serve?
In cities where the answer is “a protected lane on a key corridor” or “a new bus-rapid-transit line that actually runs on time,” you’ll have more options about how to get around. In cities where the answer is “a parking garage” or “nothing, because the state legislature blocked it,” you will be in your car. Every day. In every kind of weather.
That’s not inherently a tragedy - plenty of people move to smaller cities precisely because they want the ease of driving and the space that comes with it. But know what you’re choosing. The people making decisions about your future street grid are telling you, loudly, what they think streets are for.
Trump thought Central Park still had cars. Mitchell thinks bike lanes are a coastal affectation. These are not fringe views - they reflect the assumptions of a lot of people who hold infrastructure budgets.
The question is whether the city you’re considering has someone in charge who’s actually walked it.