In this article
The thing nobody tells you before you move to a major American city is that the people who actually know it - not the people who wrote the Yelp reviews or the “neighborhoods ranked” threads - are the ones who’ve been there long enough to remember what it used to cost to get into a nightclub. Five dollars, in Murray Hill’s case.
Murray Hill is a comedian and the author of Showbiz!, and also happens to share a name with a Manhattan neighborhood he cheerfully nominates as the fakest realtor-invented neighborhood in the city. He’s lived in New York for 35 years. He’s moved twice. That second fact is almost impossible to square with the experience of most people who land in a major city and spend the next several years getting priced out of one neighborhood into the next, further and further from where they actually wanted to be.
The secret, as anyone who has lived in New York long enough will tell you without much prompting, is rent stabilization. Hill got a rent-controlled apartment and, as he puts it: never left it.
That’s not a replicable strategy. But it’s an honest one.
What Long-Term City Residents Actually Know
There’s a specific kind of knowledge that only accumulates over decades in one place. It’s not about restaurant recommendations or which subway line runs most reliably. It’s more granular and more useful than that - it’s knowing when to say nothing, when to engage, and when to just go home.
Hill’s answer to what he’d do if his train line went down and he was running late: go home. Not heroic. Not aspirational. But if you’ve lived somewhere long enough, you know that fighting a broken transit system is a losing argument with infrastructure, and some days the city just isn’t going to cooperate.
This is the kind of calculus that new residents take years to develop. When you first arrive somewhere, you push. You reroute. You take three buses because you refuse to be defeated by a signal failure at 42nd Street. Eventually you learn - and this lesson applies whether you’re in New York or Nashville or Spokane - that the city has its own pace and the sooner you stop fighting it, the better you’ll sleep.
The Real Cost of City Living Isn’t the Rent
Hill paid ten dollars for a coffee somewhere in New York recently. His assessment: “I know, it’s bullshit.” That’s about as concise a summary of modern urban pricing as you’re going to find.
But the subtler costs are the ones worth paying attention to before you relocate. The social tax of city density - the subway manspreading, the street-flyer people, the neighbor who becomes convinced you tried to kill her with a falling air conditioner when your finger was clearly the one getting mangled - these are not small things. They accumulate.
Hill’s subway etiquette reform, if he could legislate one: “Fellas, please close your legs.” His response to being bumped by a stranger is calibrated by gender in a way that is very specifically New York and would get you into actual trouble in a smaller city where everyone knows your name and your truck.
The point is that city life requires a particular social fluency that you either develop or you don’t. For someone weighing a move to a denser American city after years somewhere quieter, that fluency has a learning curve. Hill has been building his for three and a half decades.
On the Neighborhood That Shares His Name
When asked where he’d eat in Murray Hill - the neighborhood, not the person - if he were about to pass out from hunger, his answer is the Murray Hill Diner. Not a tasting menu. Not somewhere with a three-month reservation wait. The diner.
This is, quietly, one of the more useful pieces of relocation advice you can extract from any long-term resident of any city: find the place that’s open when everything else is closed, that doesn’t require you to have planned ahead, that costs what it costs and gives you what you need. Every neighborhood worth living in has one. If yours doesn’t, that’s information.
What Actually Holds People
Hill’s best New York story isn’t about a celebrity sighting (though it was John Waters, which is a solid one). It’s about losing his wallet, and having a stranger knock on his door two days later to return it empty.
“There was nothing in it,” he says. “But he gave it back to me.”
That’s the thing about cities that the rankings built on cost-of-living indices and walkability scores and median household income can’t measure. The reason people stay - really stay, 35-year stay - usually comes down to something that happened once that they can’t quite explain. A stranger who returned an empty wallet. A diner that was open at 2am. A rent-controlled apartment they were smart enough to never leave.
Joe’s Pub, Hill says, is the best place to perform in New York City. He’s performed there with his phone going off - and answered it.
The city, apparently, did not throw him out.