In this article

Nobody moves to a city thinking about the Highway Trust Fund. They think about the apartment, the job, maybe the restaurant scene. But the Trust Fund - chronically underfunded, now facing pressure from Congress to cut fuel taxes further - is the upstream source of whether the bus line near your new place runs every eight minutes or every forty. Researchers at the Tax Policy Center have proposed options for shoring it up, including raising gas taxes if prices drop enough to make it politically survivable. Whether that actually happens will determine, in a very material way, whether American cities can afford the transit networks they’ve been promising.

That context matters if you’re choosing where to plant yourself.

The cities doing the work, and the ones stalling

Tampa just approved its first downtown north-south protected bike lanes. That’s not a small thing for a Sun Belt city built almost entirely around the car - it’s the kind of incremental shift that suggests someone in city hall has decided to take the question seriously. Whether the lanes survive the first round of merchant complaints is another matter, but the baseline commitment is there.

St. Paul, on the other hand, recently agreed to pay $180,000 to settle a lawsuit brought by an anti-bike lane group. Read that again: a city cut a six-figure check to opponents of its own infrastructure. Whatever you think about the bike lanes themselves, that outcome tells you something about how much political durability those projects actually have.

Utah is roughly $500 million short for a rail line that state officials have described as essential to hosting the 2034 Winter Olympics - a deadline that is not moving. Colorado residents are actively pushing for more passenger rail between Denver and cities like Boulder, which today has no direct train connection to a capital city forty miles away. These are not abstract policy debates. If you’re considering Denver, “I’ll take the train to Boulder” is not currently a sentence you can finish.

The parking problem is everywhere, and it’s not going away

D.C. residents are blocking new development over parking concerns. Not affordability, not building height, not shadow studies - parking. This is a city with one of the better transit systems in the country, and a meaningful share of its residents are still organized primarily around car storage.

This is worth understanding before you relocate, because the parking question shapes almost everything else: what gets built and where, how dense a neighborhood can become, whether a corner that could hold a café or a small apartment building instead holds twelve cars on asphalt. A Cleveland university and hospital are currently partnering to demolish existing buildings in order to create more surface parking. In 2025. That’s not a mistake or a local anomaly - it’s a revealed preference.

What you actually save by not driving

San Francisco is an extreme case in almost every respect, but one figure from the San Francisco Examiner is worth sitting with: transit commuters there save nearly $20,000 a year compared to drivers, once you account for car ownership, insurance, fuel, and parking. San Francisco is not a model most smaller cities are replicating. But the underlying math - car ownership as a significant recurring tax on your income - applies anywhere you’re likely to land.

The cities where you can genuinely live without a car are still a short list. The cities where you can get by with a car you rarely need are a longer one, and growing. The cities where you will spend a meaningful fraction of your income on a vehicle you resent are the majority.

Speed cameras and the limits of enforcement

Tacoma installed new speed cameras at an intersection and recorded roughly 400,000 speeding violations in a single month - more than three-quarters of every driver who passed through. The volume was large enough to overwhelm the vendor processing the tickets. The takeaway isn’t that Tacoma drivers are unusually reckless. It’s that roads designed to encourage speed will be driven at speed, regardless of the posted limit, and that camera enforcement at a single intersection doesn’t change the underlying geometry.

If a city’s traffic safety strategy is cameras and fines rather than street redesign, you now know what that strategy produces.

The question nobody asks on the relocation tour

Waymo is planning to expand its robotaxi fleet to 20,000 vehicles by the end of next year. Sound Transit spent part of this month reassuring Ballard residents that their light rail line is still actually happening. Atlanta’s MARTA is facing sharply rising renovation costs at its Five Points hub. These are all different cities, different scales, different problems - but they share a common thread: transit infrastructure is expensive, contested, and perpetually underfunded, and the gap between what cities promise and what they deliver is where your daily life will eventually land.

The right question to ask before you move isn’t “does this city have good transit?” It’s “what is this city actually spending on transit right now, and what happened the last time someone tried to cut a bike lane?”

The St. Paul settlement check was $180,000. Someone had to approve that.