In this article
London is currently building roughly 37% of the apartments it needs to meet government targets, according to data from Molior. That number is not a rounding error. It is a policy failure dressed up as a market outcome - and the week of news that produced it should matter to anyone relocating to an American city and trying to read the housing market honestly.
Here is what happened. British Land and pension fund AustralianSuper are joint partners on a 53-acre regeneration project at Canada Water in south London. The full scheme is planned for more than 4,000 homes and 2.5 million square feet of workspace. Phase one, which included 186 homes, has sold about 30% of its units. Phase two - up to 408 additional homes - has been deferred indefinitely. The reason given: construction costs are up, sales values are down, and the math stopped working.
The same week, Landsec announced it was shelving plans for 1,744 apartments on a 17-acre site in Lewisham. The project had received approval last October. It included social rent units, discounted market-rate housing, and units allocated for key workers - the kind of affordable breakdown that cities everywhere publicly demand and privately make nearly impossible to finance. Landsec needed the local council to agree to compulsory purchases of adjacent properties to assemble the site. The council changed hands in May elections. The Green Party, now in control, declined to support the purchases. Project over.
Two schemes. One week. More than 2,000 homes that aren’t getting built.
Why This Is an American Story Too
None of the underlying forces here are exclusive to London. Rising construction costs have stalled or killed projects in Austin, Nashville, Phoenix, and Raleigh over the past two years. The same squeeze - labor costs up, materials costs up, interest rates up, buyer appetite uncertain - is running through pro forma spreadsheets in every market where there was a development boom. The projects that made sense at 2021 financing rates frequently don’t pencil at 2024 rates. Developers don’t announce this loudly. They quietly pause, defer, or let approvals expire.
What makes the London situation instructive rather than merely depressing is how visible the political layer is. The Canada Water project got revised planning approval in March for increased height and density - a concession cities rarely make easily - and still couldn’t move forward. The Lewisham project was fully approved and then effectively killed when a new council majority refused a routine land-assembly step. Both outcomes reflect something worth naming: the distance between a project being approved and a project being built can be enormous, and that distance is where housing supply quietly disappears.
In American cities, the same gap shows up differently. Rezonings happen; projects stall at the permitting stage. Affordable housing mandates get attached; developers walk. Council members approve density in principle and then object to specific buildings on specific blocks. The mechanism varies. The result is the same.
What Relocators Actually Need to Watch
If you’re moving to a smaller American city because you expect more housing supply and more reasonable rents, the right question isn’t whether new apartments are being approved. It’s whether they’re actually getting built.
Check certificate-of-occupancy data, not permit data. Permits are intentions. Certificates of occupancy are finished units. In many markets, the gap between the two has widened significantly since 2022.
Look at what share of planned affordable units in a given development are actually deed-restricted versus income-averaged. The Canada Water scheme, as a whole, was projecting 9% affordable housing across a 4,000-unit development - a number that would draw criticism in most American cities but reflects the real ceiling that financing constraints impose.
Pay attention to political transitions. The Lewisham situation - approved project, new council majority, withdrawn support - can happen in any city with an elected planning board or city council that controls site assembly, tax increment financing, or infrastructure commitments. A project that was viable under one administration may not survive the next.
The Specific Thing to Ask Before You Sign a Lease
Find out how many units are currently under construction within a mile of wherever you’re looking to rent or buy. Not planned. Not approved. Under construction. That number will tell you more about where your rent is heading than any “livability” index.
In most of the smaller American cities worth relocating to right now - places where the fundamentals are real and the hype hasn’t fully outrun reality - that number is either holding steady or beginning to thin. The pipeline that was launched in 2021 and 2022 is delivering. The pipeline that was supposed to follow it is not always there.
London’s 37% delivery rate against target is an extreme case. But most American cities aren’t building at 100% of what they need either, and the projects that would close the gap are facing the same cost pressures that just killed 2,000 homes in a single week in one of the wealthiest cities on earth.
The question isn’t whether your target city has cranes on the skyline. It’s whether those cranes are still moving.